Description

We've got too much, which means you're in luck. We'll surprise you with what we send! Let the fun begin! 

All Mystery Items are final sale. Mystery items could be any shirt from our lifestyle or seasonal collections. Due to limited stock, we cannot guarantee that you will not receive a duplicate tee, however, we will do our best to make sure you receive unique shirts. Due to the nature of it being a mystery, we cannot promise which style you will receive (crewneck, v-neck, or tank top). Available while supplies lasts.

Exchanges & Returns

Feel free to return unworn merchandise within 10 days of receipt (more flexible during the holidays). Why 10 days? Because we noticed the longer it takes, the more funky and damaged garments can get. Dog hair. People hair. Glitter. And even some stank on occasion. No fun. So that's how we landed at the number 10. Seasonal items such as Christmas designs are eligible for exchange only.

If you'd like to make an exchange, please click here to make an exchange.

Buy 3, get the 4th free
1
2
3Free shipping

More designs you’ll love

Tap a shirt to add it in your size. No need to leave the page.

Chicken Butt View
Chicken Butt
$36.00
The Skyline View
The Skyline
$36.00
Be Kind View
Be Kind
$36.00
Rockford Peaches View
Rockford Peaches
$36.00
Flamingo Kicks View
Flamingo Kicks
$36.00
Smiling Elf View
Smiling Elf
$36.00
Keep it Poppin View
Keep it Poppin
$34.00
Flamingo in Heels View
Flamingo in Heels
$28.00
Not Today View
Not Today
$36.00
Castle View
Castle
$36.00
Texas Bluebonnet View
Texas Bluebonnet
$34.00
Augusta Golf View
Augusta Golf
$36.00
American Boom Shaka Laka View
American Boom Shaka Laka
$36.00
Buffalo Fans View
Buffalo Fans
$34.00
Be Merry View
Be Merry
$36.00
Greatest of All Time (GOAT) View
Greatest of All Time (GOAT)
$34.00
Blue Jean Baby View
Blue Jean Baby
$36.00
Nacho Average Madre View
Nacho Average Madre
$36.00
Carolina Strong View
Carolina Strong
$36.00
I Really Really Miss Hawaii View
I Really Really Miss Hawaii
$36.00
Baseball Heart View
Baseball Heart
$36.00
Mama Bear View
Mama Bear
$36.00
Boy Mama View
Boy Mama
$36.00
Oh Fudge View
Oh Fudge
$36.00

Shop Basics

Our Basics are insanely soft and comfortable.

View more

  • 5 stars: 115 (91%)
  • 4 stars: 12 (9%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
K
Kylie Hill
Awesome selection

Both shirts were perfect and love them both!

R
Rachel Smith
Disappointing

I opted for the mystery item because I thought it would be fun to get. I received the Mama Bear sweatshirt and was disappointed and honestly shocked that this particular line would be included in the Mystery offering. As someone who has plenty of friends that have struggled through the battle of infertility, I felt this was a sensitive type item to include in any mystery offering. I chose to contact the customer service to let them know that maybe they shouldn’t include this line due to the potential sensitivity around it. The person that responded simply quoted policy to me which was disappointing. In this day and age, I would think an instance like this would prompt conversation and an understanding as opposed to dismissing it through policy. Very disappointing and I will certainly not recommend the mystery item to anyone.

D
Dana Matchem
I like it a lot!

I like the Mystery T because I know I’m getting a quality T-shirt. Whatever the print, I’m going to get a soft and durable T-shirt. And for that reason I am a fan of the Mystery T. My most recent one was my favorite!

S
Shellie Hughes
Love it!

The most perfect shirt. Will definitely be ordering more!

Y
Yvonne Sandomir
Love it!!!

It was just as I expected.

D
Dave Gabriel

This chill T-shirt was a mystery item so I had no idea what it was going to be and I am very satisfied

E
Emily Spence
Exciting!

I love how soft the shirts are! The Mystery T was also really exciting! Was I going to get one I already had? I got a great, soft, funny shirt that makes me smile. Which one was it? It's a mystery!

M
Moria Frazer
Funny mystery shirt

Wasn't sure what to expect as a mystery shirt. It's not my style, but it's funny and wearable around the house as PJs. Very comfy!!

S
Sarah McClelland
Awesome T-Shirt

Awesome soft and great quality

A
Amanda Gravina
Mystery T

Love it!

J
Julie Swiderski
Home Run!!

The mystery t-shirt was awesome! I bought a shirt for my husband and decided to get a mystery shirt for myself and you did not disappoint! The Rockford Peaches shirt made my whole day! It fit perfectly, was so soft, and was an absolute perfect pick for me!!

J
Jill Brick
It’s perfect!

The mystery shirt was great, I already had it, actually, in a smaller size, now I can wear the new one as a night shirt , and it’s even more appropriate !

K
Kirsten Toler
Awesome

I’m always down for a surprise, and the shirt that arrived was perfect for our oldest daughter; the funny saying on the shirt was perfect for a psych major and the fit and softness made it the perfect gift.

K
Kathy Sather
Fun surprise

A fun surprise, a Christmas T, so will wait for next year to wear it, or I will sleep in it!

T
Theresa Jones
Loved my surprise shirt!!

It was so awesome, enjoyed it!

D
Doug La3
Mystery T

I wasn't sure what I'd get but I wasn't disappointed!! Mahalo!!

A
Angel Thompson-Broussard
Fun Shirt

I was excited to receive my mystery shirt., It was a cute design and I was happy with my purchase. As with all the home Ts , it's just as soft and comfortable as the rest.

T
Tiffany Rawlings
Soft!

I was super happy with the design (Woke up sexy as Hell again). The shirt is a relaxed fit and super soft!

G
Gayle Erhart
? T-shirt

I loved it.

S
Steven Goldstein
Awesome

Great Shirt and very timely with the passing of the Queen.

G
Gerri Mazer
Fun all around

It was fun ordering a mystery shirt and exciting waiting for it to arrive to see what I would get. I figured I’d get a gray home state T-shirt from a boring random state but instead I got a really cool shirt with a saying that I love and would have gotten for myself. I was also excited that it was a nice blue color. Thanks Home T!

B
Brady Wilkins
Best t-shirts

Not what I would have picked for a mystery tshirt, but has same comfort so I’ll wear it and enjoy!

L
Leisa Jarrett
MYSTERY T

loved the mystery T - was very pleasantly surprised

C
Carol Rakoczy
Great buy!

I loved every one of the shirts! Couldn’t tell there was anything wrong with them. I received two Texas, one Boston, one dachshund, and one Tobacco Road. The only one that I won’t wear out of the house is Tobacco Road.

F
Fallen Lyndie
Mystery T

It was so fun opening up the mystery T!! I love it.

B
Brenda Penton
Bad Mystery Tee

I called and told y’all how disappointed I was in the tee shirt. Sorry😥 The tee said Woke Still Sexy as Hell. Inappropriate for a 76 year old woman to wear out. Y’all need to think about that when you pick the Mystery Tee. I had looked forward to getting it. I loved my other shirts. Thanks.

S
Susan Shackelford
It did not arrive

I ordered T-shirts as gifts for my office. I reached out via email but still have not heard a response about the mystery T-shirt not arriving.

A
Andrea Lenahan
Mystery T

I love my mystery T-shirt perfect to wear to school as I’m a teacher celebrating Twosday!

A
Annie Davis
Awesome Tshirts

These TShirts are awesome! So comfy and great quality!

S
Stacey Pierce
Christmas Tee

The tee is cool. Just wish it wasn’t a Christmas tee. I wouldn’t have bought a mystery Christmas tee this time of year.

J
Jacklyn Premak
Mystery T Shirt

Loved my mystery shirt! It was perfect gift for one of kids!

E
Ellen Gallagher
Super soft

Very soft and comfortable, but was really hoping it wasn’t Xmas related as I had just ordered a Xmas shirt

E
Elizabeth Kurt
Sssooooooooo soft!

I got the mystery shirt and it did not disappoint! Perfect design for me and the fabric is sooooo soft!